Report by Remedy
Eureka, CA - A jam-packed audience attended a public workshop that
aired
concerns surrounding controversial logging plans by Maxxam/Pacific
Lumber and the flooded-out residents who oppose them. In front of
a
standing room only crowd that spilled into the lobby, opposing sides
gave their best to convince the North Coast Regional Water Board that
they should or shouldnt approve permits for waste
discharge for
logging in two impaired Humboldt County valleys.
Maxxam/PL president Robert Manne said the timber company was in
financial crisis, and that California will be a
lot worse off if the
permits associated with the logging plans are not granted. PL scientist
Jeff Barrett tried to demonstrate that logging would help rather than
further harm the heavily-logged area, saying elimination of
all harvest
effects would do almost nothing to reduce flood frequency.
Thats tobacco science, said McKinleyville resident
Dr. Ken Miller.
Really, smoking is good for you.
A fiery presentation by Humboldt Watershed Council president Mark
Lovelace used PLs own documents to show it knew increased logging
would
cause flooding and lay-offs after the boom-and-bust timber cutting
that
followed Maxxams hostile take-over of PL. Lovelace also said
he was
frustrated that PL lobbyists had met for several days
with the water
board in Santa Rosa without any input from affected downstream
residents. Its like putting a smiley face on a pigs butt,
he said.
Any way you look at it, its dirty, its ugly and it stinks.
Lovelace also questioned how a corporation that has earned $3.6 billion
dollars in the last twenty years could be on the verge of bankruptcy.
Where did the money go, he asked.
Elk River resident and farmer Kristi Wrigley said she first brought
the
flooding issues to the water board eight years ago, and that damage
from
over-logging is annually getting worse. Wrigley is the first downstream
landowner on a farm thats been in her family for over a hundred
years.
Im the best empirical science you have available,
she said. It is
extremely offensive that you have spent 4 days talking to the polluter.
Long time Elk River resident Jim Holdner said he didnt see the
damage
the other residents described, and that water quality in that valley
has
always been bad. But another long-timer, Phillip Nicholous, said a
person would have to be brain dead not to see the damage
Maxxam/PL has
cause Elk River.
Were here because of one mans greed, said
attorney William Bertain,
who has represented former shareholders, PL retirees and local residents
in lawsuits against Maxxam, a Texas corporation which treats Freshwater
Creek and Elk River as ditches for their industrial waste.
During the rebuttal period of the workshop, PL general counsel Jared
Carter said PLs 1990 Pacific Meridian Report cited by Lovelace
to show
decline in both timber and jobs pre-dated the Maxxam take-over, and
had
nothing to do with how the company is run today. Lovelace easily put
the
lie to the corporate attorney by producing a copy of the Report, which
cites the option of returning to the 1985 harvest level.
1985 was the
year Maxxam took over the company and doubled the rate of cut.
Other PL lawyers have publicly stated the company has free speech
rights when negotiating with the state, otherwise known as the famous
right-to-lie defense for the alleged fraud committed by
the company
during the Headwaters Forest negotiations.
At the conclusion of the meeting, Water Board Executive Officer
Katherine Kuhlman said she would make her decision on Thursday, February
24, 2005. PLs financial situation will not play a role in her
final
decision, she said.