Upper Cummings Creek Catchment Area

Driving east on Highway 36, Cummings Creek is located between Wilson Creek and Fox Creek monitoring sites but is actually much closer to Fox Creek. Cummings Creek is a direct tributary to the main stem Van Duzen River, merging with the main stem in the lower basin considerably downstream from where it emerges at the river bar. Cummings Creek runs downstream parallel to the main stem for a considerable distance before it merges with the river. The monitoring site is located in the redwoods with a sizable buffer zone of hardwoods like Red Alder and Oak within the riparian zone around the stream. Above the site is a catchment area with about 10.5 miles of stream network. Elevations in Cummings Creek range from 118 feet at its mouth to over 2.600 feet in the upper reaches, and the monitoring site is approximately 335 feet in elevation. The watershed is completely in private ownership with most of the timber holdings and timber harvests by Humboldt Redwood Company (formerly PALCO). Vegetation is predominantly Mixed and Evergreen (Redwood) Forest throughout. The catchment area of a monitoring site is important when considering upslope factors that affect water quality in the stream. This area represents the true watershed that lies above the point where water from the stream is sampled, and from which all rain and sediment are channeled into the stream down to the point where water is withdrawn for turbidity and suspended sediment analysis.

Stream discharge is directly proportional to the size of the catchment area - the greater the area, the more water is carried by the stream during storm events. The Cummings Creek catchment area is about average in size compared with the other areas within the project area, and the stream drains an area of approximately 10.4 square kilometers which is equivalent to 4.0 square miles. During the first year of sampling (HY07) volunteers recorded a maximum discharge of 239 cubic feet per second (CFS) and an average discharge of 30 CFS, a maximum turbidity of 852 Nephlometric Units (NTU) and an average turbidity of 92 NTU. In HY08, there was a maximum discharge of 1,115 CFS and an average discharge of 132 CFS, a maximum turbidity of 2,380 NTU and an average turbidity of 237 NTU over the winter sampling season. Over the two seasons combined (HY07-HY08), the maximum discharge was in HY08 at 1,115 CFS with an average of 62 CFS, maximum turbidity was also in HY08 at 2,380 NTU with an average of 139 NTU. This translates to an average of 1,306 tons of suspended sediment per square mile per year.

Cummings Creek runs year round at the upper monitoring site, and is therefore considered to be a perennial stream (as opposed to an ephemeral stream, which runs dry in the summer). Maximum weekly average temperature (MWAT) in the summer of 2007 was 15.36 C, and in 2008 it was 14.84 C. Overall, temperatures were relatively cool compared to many of the other streams sampled within the lower basin project area, as Upper Cummings Creek, along with Hely Creek, typically registered the coldest temperatures of all the streams in the lower basin. Upper Cummings Creek has a road density of about 8.9 miles of roads per square mile of watershed. As with all of the catchment areas within the lower basin, this density of road networks receives a rating of extremely high. In the 17-year period from 1991 through 2007, the proportion of the area harvested for timber equaled 110%, with clear cutting accounting for 10.6% of the total watershed area. Proportions greater than 100% are possible because areas are calculated to include re-entry over multiple years. Calculation of overlapping THPs in forested areas helps quantify the impacts of re-entry by logging operations over multiple years, and sheds additional light on a process known as cumulative effects.


Looking upstream at the Upper Cummings Creek monitoring site. Note staff plate in center right of picture. Photo by K. Bromley.
Looking upstream at the Upper Cummings Creek monitoring site. Note staff plate in center right of picture.
(Photo by K. Bromley)
Upper Cummings Creek near flooding after a major storm event. Photo by K. Bromley.
Upper Cummings Creek near flooding after a major storm event. (Photo by K. Bromley)

Upper Cummings Creek after a moderate storm event. Photo by K. Bromley.
Upper Cummings Creek after a moderate storm event.
(Photo by K. Bromley)

Measuring stream flow for calculating discharge at the Upper Cummings Creek Monitoring site. Photo by P. Trichilo.
Measuring stream flow for calculating discharge at the Upper Cummings Creek Monitoring site. (Photo by S. Steinberg)

Friends of the Van Duzen River
PO Box 315
Carlotta, CA 95528